Out of the Box's 2025/2026 season concluded with a production of TRASH by James Caverly and Andrew Morrill in collaboration with The PAC NYC. The production was presented by the PAC and ran for 3 weeks, with rave reviews, and was performed in American Sign Language and English.

Following her time at Theater 154, Liz Flemming signed a 10-year lease to take over Saint Luke's Theater. Out of the Box ended up moving in 3 months earlier than planned to transfer their production of Beau to Midtown. They came on as both lead producers and General Managers for a commercial Off-Broadway run.

Two and a half years after taking over Theater 154 (the previous New Ohio Theater), Liz Flemming closed out OOTB's programming with their 2025 production of Beau by Douglas Lyons and Ethan D. Pakchar. BroadwayWorld highlights from Beau the Musical at Theatre 154 The chapter at 154 ended in August 2025 to a sold-out run and rave reviews with a band of brilliant artists led by Matt Rodin as Ace Baker.